Comcast and quality of HD

As you can imagine, the cable coming into your house for TV has a finite amount of bandwidth. That same bandwidth must be used for TV, Internet and telephone (if you use cable telephone). This is all well and good and is not limitation assuming that the combination of those three services does not exceed the available bandwidth. Bandwidth was not really an issue until the advent HDTV. High definition TV requires more bandwidth since it is a more detailed picture with more pixels. The problem then is how you can squeeze more HDTV channels into the existing bandwidth. The simple solution is compression. You just compress the incoming data which reduces bandwidth requirements, but at a cost of a reduction in image quality. This is exactly what Comcast is doing according to this post at avsforum.  This poster performs a detailed side-by-side comparison between Comcast and FiOS HD channels and finds that the image quality is noticably worse with Comcast.  This is certainly an interesting finding and lends more creditability to the suggestion that FiOS would be a substantial upgrade over Comcast.

(Visited 69 times, 1 visits today)

One thought on “Comcast and quality of HD”

  1. That is such an insightful article. I also notice detoriation of performance while playing X Box Live. It takes a long time to shoot a person and by the time I am able to pull the trigger, the enemy has already bitch slapped me. I always thought it was my age, arthritis and alzhiemer, but now I know its comcast that has been screewing around with my head.

    I hate you comcast! I would rather connect using the good old fashioned modem.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.